dynamic Pricing Icon

Value Game

The Value Game applies when an offering creates economic or emotional value that customers cannot easily obtain elsewhere. High-technology, luxury, and pharmaceutical companies often fit this environment. Their differentiation limits direct competition, while a broad base of buyers prevents any one customer from influencing the nature of the transaction. 

That market position gives the company meaningful pricing freedom, but it does not guarantee success. Value Game players must understand the value they create, decide how much of it to share with customers, and select a pricing model that can scale as usage or outcomes expand. They also need sustained innovation and marketing to keep the offer differentiated and protect the value customers perceive. 

A high price is not the defining feature. A company may intentionally share substantial value to accelerate adoption, build an ecosystem, or establish a market. Another may retain more value through higher margins. The strategic decision is how price supports long-term growth while preserving a fair and compelling exchange with customers. 

ChatGPT Image Sep 28 2026 02 20 19 PM

What Is the Value Game

The Value Game is one of the seven pricing games in the Strategic Pricing Hexagon. It fits markets where the seller has a clearly differentiated offering, customers perceive significant benefits from it, and buyers are numerous enough that no individual account has significant purchasing power. Value-based pricing is the principal method because costs are a poor approximation of the value that customers perceive and competitor prices reflect a different value proposition than the one behind the Value Game player’s highly differentiated offering. 

Customer value has several dimensions. At the highest level it comprises substitute value and usage value. Usage value, in turn, can be functional, emotional, or both. Substitute value compares the offering directly to its next best alternative. Usage value is what powers the high level of differentiation. Along the economic dimension, functional value can come from measurable, quantifiable, and usually economic dimensions such as greater revenue, lower operating costs, reduced risk, saved time, improved health, or better performance. Emotional value may come from status, confidence, identity, design, trust, or enjoyment. A credible price needs to reflect the relevant sources of value without assuming that every customer perceives them equally. 

The company must also defend the connection between price and value. Innovation strengthens the offering and extends the differentiation, while branding and communication make the benefits apparent to customers. If competitors catch up, the narrative weakens and the level of differentiation narrows. As price differentials become harder to defend, the company may need to consider moving to a different pricing game.

When Companies Should Play the Value Game

The Value Game is most relevant when several market characteristics occur together.

  • The offering delivers benefits that materially exceed available alternatives.
  • Differentiation is difficult for competitors to copy quickly.
  • Customers recognize or can be shown the economic or emotional value.
  • The buyer base is broad enough that no individual customer influences pricing.
  • The company can support its claims with evidence, experience, brand strength, or outcomes.
  • Ongoing innovation and marketing can protect the value proposition.

A differentiated product is not automatically a Value Game offer. If a small number of powerful buyers negotiate every agreement, the Power Game may fit better. If customer needs divide into well-defined segments, the company may move toward the Choice Game. If differentiation erodes and alternatives become comparable, Uniform or Custom Game logic may become more important.

ChatGPT Image Sep 28 2026 02 21 51 PM
ChatGPT Image Sep 28 2026 02 20 19 PM

How the Value Game Works

Value Game players estimate the value created for customers, choose how much of that value to share, and design a pricing model that aligns payment with the way customers receive benefits. Research can include customer interviews, value-driver analysis, willingness-to-pay studies, market experiments, usage data, and evidence from comparable customer decisions. 

The price should leave customers with a reason to adopt. A company may share more value to penetrate a market, encourage trial, stimulate complementary innovation, or build network effects. It may retain more when supply is constrained, differentiation is strong, or the offer creates immediate and measurable benefits. These are strategic choices, not outputs from a formula alone. 

The pricing model can be as important as the price point. A one-time purchase, subscription, usage charge, razor-and-blades model, performance fee, or outcome-based agreement changes how value and risk are shared. The right basis makes the price easier to understand and allows revenue to grow as customer value grows. 

How to Win the Value Game

Airlines and Hospitality

Quantify Customer Value

Identify the outcomes that matter and estimate their economic or emotional importance. The analysis should distinguish substitute value, which will face more direct competition, and usage value. The company should also recognize that customers differ in their ability to realize the benefit.

image 1

Decide How Much Value to Share

A pricing strategy is company’s conscious philosophy on how to share value with customers, and the price is the mechanism for the desired amount of sharing. Sharing more value with customers can improve adoption and long-term growth. Retaining more value can generate the resources to fund innovation and may also reflect scarcity or superior performance. The decision should support the broader market strategy.

Retail and E-Commerce

Choose a Pricing Model That Scales With Value

The pricing basis should follow the customer’s value drivers when practical. Some models in the value game are simple, while others are a function of usage, outcomes, or specific measures of performance. Tiered offerings provide a way for customers to trade up for a premium or ultra high value experience.

Entertainment Events

Communicate and Defend the Value

Customers need a clear reason to believe the offer is worth its price and that the value or the experience will not diminish over time. Marketing and brand experience play a critical role when value is emotional and quantitative evidence doesn’t have the same weight in the customer’s perception. Price discipline is also critical to preserving the value perception and defending value. Players in the Value Game rarely if ever offer discounts.

Software and Digital Services

Keep Innovating

Differentiation erodes when competitors improve or customer expectations rise. Product development, service improvement, ecosystem investment, and new use cases can renew the value proposition and preserve pricing freedom.

Software and Digital Services

Monitor Value Erosion

Declining usage, weaker willingness to pay, rising discount pressure, negative comparisons, or reduced engagement can signal misalignment between price and value. Companies may respond by changing the product, communication, access, or the pricing model.

Value Game Pricing Examples

Software as a Service and subscription services

Technology and Software

A differentiated technology can introduce new capabilities that create functional value (such as greater efficiency, risk reduction, or ease of use) or emotional value (such as entertainment or social integration). Early prices can also encourage developers and customers to build an ecosystem with network effects.

Media and entertainment

Luxury Goods

Luxury offers combine function with design, craftsmanship, scarcity, identity, status, and experience. Marketing and controlled distribution help preserve the emotional value. Discounting or inconsistent presentation can damage the value perception that supports the price.

Restaurants and food service

Pharmaceuticals and Healthcare

A treatment can create value through longer life, better health, reduced hospital use, restored productivity, lower future costs, or an outright cure. Pricing models may involve a course of treatment based on patient, population, or outcome. National systems vary in how their pricing affects access, affordability, and fairness.

Banking and financial services

Professional and Intellectual Property-Based Services

Specialized expertise, proprietary methods, data, or intellectual property can create benefits whose value is hard to reflect in terms of the provider’s hours or production cost. The challenge lies in pricing based on scope, access, performance, or business outcomes, mutually agreed between provider and client.

Benefits and Risks of the Value Game

Potential benefits Common risks
Price can reflect superior economic or emotional value The company overestimates value or confuses novelty with enduring differentiation
Value sharing can accelerate adoption and market growth A high price restricts access or slows ecosystem development
Scalable pricing models keep revenue aligned with customer benefits Complex models are difficult to monitor or explain
Innovation and branding create and protect degrees of freedom in pricing Competitors catch up if the company relies on past differentiation
Strong evidence of value evidence reduces focus on cost Weak or inconsistent communication risks making the offer appear overpriced

Value Game Compared With Other Pricing Games

  • Value Game vs. Choice Game: Value players align the price of a highly differentiated offer with customer value. Choice players build a structured lineup to serve multiple segments. A successful Value Game company may add tiers as the market broadens. 
  • Value Game vs. Power Game: Value players serve fragmented buyers who have limited individual leverage. Power players face concentrated buyers and a few competitors, and all parties need to weigh the consequences of each negotiation and each strategic reaction.
  • Value Game vs. Uniform Game: Players in each game may use uniform prices, but the market characteristics are much different. Value players are highly differentiated and defend it with intensive value communication. Uniform players compete against numerous comparable sellers in large markets where understanding price elasticity is critical.
  • Value Game vs. Custom Game: Value players have considerable pricing freedom because an individual buyer’s influence is low. Custom players negotiate account-specific deals amid strong competition and greater buyer influence.
ChatGPT Image Sep 28 2026 12 51 42 PM

FAQS

What is the Value Game in pricing?

The Value Game is a pricing strategy for differentiated offerings that create substantial economic or emotional customer value. The seller has limited direct competition and serves a broad buyer base, allowing the seller more leeway to decide how much value to share with customers.

What is value-based pricing?

Value-based pricing is a methodology which uses the customers’ perceived value as the primary input for setting prices. It requires robust insights into what drives value, how much customers are willing to pay for it, and how to communicate that value forcefully. It contrasts with a cost-plus methodology, which uses costs and a margin target as the inputs for pricing decisions, and with a competition-based methodology, which relies on the prices for alternatives as the basis for price-setting.

How do companies measure customer value?

Companies use a range of quantitative and qualitative techniques to measure value. These can include economic or financial calculations to quantify benefits or outcomes such as revenue gains, output gains, cost savings and time savings. They can also use quantitative techniques such as conjoint analysis, maximum differential analysis (Max-Diff) or A/B testing to understand willingness to pay for incremental changes in benefits. Finally, they can use qualitative methods such as in-depth interviews, focus groups, or day-in-the-life observation of customer behavior.

Why would a Value Game player leave money on the table?

Chasing the highest short-term margin is not always the best long-term strategy. Sharing more value – through lower prices or additional features – can accelerate adoption, attract complementary investment, build network effects, support access, and create stronger customer relationships.

Which pricing models fit the Value Game?

Value game players can choose from several pricing models as long as the chosen model is easy to communicate and remains aligned with value as the business scales. These include transactional models, subscriptions, usage-based pricing, and outcome-based agreements.

How does a company lose the Value Game?

The two drivers of sustained success in the Value Game are constant innovation to maintain or expand differentiation and strong messaging to communicate and support the value resulting from the differentiation. When either of those drivers slows, it creates opportunities for customers to see alternatives and for competitors to close gaps and can lead to a misalignment between price and value. A player may then shift to an adjacent game (Choice or Uniform) or make a more fundamental change and play the Custom Game if the new market characteristics fit.

More Dynamic Pricing Insights

The En$hittification of soccer?

No, I am not writing that headline because France has lost. As always, France had the talent to win, but counted too much on the supposed brilliance of their star…
—> Read more

Changing the Narrative on World Cup Ticket Pricing

Have you noticed that the furor around the prices for World Cup tickets has died down since the tournament started? There are good reasons for that, and they offer some…
—> Read more

Winning the Value Game

When Apple launched its Vision Pro headset in June, the price point of $3,499 grabbed many of the headlines and sparked countless discussions. Was the price too high? Was it…
—> Read more

Welcome to The Game Changer Newsletter

What is your pricing strategy? Business leaders often answer that question by citing a method such as “charging what the market will bear” or applying a markup to costs. Some…
—> Read more

White House plan to eliminate Hep C

Thanks Dave for sharing. It has been a labor of love and persistence and you have been at the center of it. Great to see a comprehensive plan proposed at…
—> Read more